Halak in, Metro doubtful, AK46 demoted

posted by Pat Hickey at 10h53 EST on Oct 26


Jaroslav Halak was the first goaltender off the ice at today's morning skate will means tonight against the Islanders he'll get his fourth consecutive start. The last time Halak started four straight was last Feb. 21-28. He won all four, blanked Vancouver and had a save percentage of .952 in that stretch.

Glen Metropolit is doubtful for tonight's game. He stayed home from the morning skate because of the flu. 

There were several lines changes but the most significant sees Andrei Kostitsyn dropped to the fourth line. He practiced this morning with Kyle Chipchura and Gregory Stewart. 

The second line has Tomas Plekanec betweeen Guillaume Latendresse and Matt D'Agostini. Maxim Lapierre, who played well as a second-line winger in the past two games, is back at centre because of the questions about Metropolit's health. His linemates are Max Pacioretty and Travis Moen. 

AUDIO: Jacques Martin | Guillaume Latendresse | Kyle Chipchura | Gregory Stewart




StumbleUpon

Comments

[Jump to comment form]

I was just at the bell centre and saw Metro filling up gas across the street, he was looking just fine and said hes playing tonight. So Look for him in the lineup!


SeriousFan09's picture

I just don't see Lats finishing this game on the 2nd line by any stretch of the imagination, he'll be lagging behind Matt and Pleky the whole 1st period, granted at least it gives Lapierre a chance to run the 3rd line without the boat anchor that's tied to him whenever he's played next to Gui this season.

I'm okay with Halak starting this, but I would have rather seen Price get a chance to start and win on home ice, the way the team is playing now he could get that without being expected to stand on his head for 60 minutes. But Jaro is the starter right now and Martin is going with it so we'll see what happens.

Not optimistic about seeing Stewart on that 4th line at all though, that 4th line could be a real liability with him on it. Hoepfully AK46 words hard and get himself bumped up a couple of lines during the game, I just don't see secondary scoring happening because Lats is on the 2nd, more likely Moen and Lapierre will combine for a goal.

- I shall always remember Captain Koivu.


matraque's picture

LOL.

--------------

We have a new team!

Mike Komisarek: (-2)-0-(-2)

Gainey Haters bandwagon ---> This way


100HABS's picture

Someone below mentioned brother acts. I couldn't help but search quickly on the internet about the stats on the Rockets. Here's what Wikipedia says:

Played together for the Montreal Canadiens from 1955 to 1960. Won the Stanley Cup all five years they played together. Henri won 11 Stanley Cups, a record for a player; combined with Maurice’s 8, they own the record for most Stanley Cups by any combination of brothers.

Imagine that - five years they play together, five Stanley Cups... It must have been nice to be a Habs fan back then.


SmartDog's picture

YEAH!!!  The Kostitsyns are next BABY!!

....uh, maybe not...

--------------------------------------------------- `Could this team miss the playoffs? Who knows?' - Bob Gainey on the new Habs.


Halak has played bottom feeders and is getting praised for his efforts. He was lucky to get a W on Saturday night. Halak was very shanky at times and let out big reboundsThe team won the game for him. CP will not be back next season. You heard it first on HI/O. IMO, CP deserves to play tonight. This would have been a tune up game for him and be ready to play against Pittsburgh. But no, Jack (*ss) Martin decides to go win the winning formal. Habs will have their hands full tonight and they will see a different NYI team tonight. Habs better be ready to play cause the NYI are fresh and eager for a win and this game is not BACK TO BACK for NYI. Doug weight should be in the Islanders line up as well. Halak will be tested big time tonight.


petefleet's picture

Take your meds man, something might pop if you don't.

Go Habs Go


Bugs's picture
Shockingly ridiculous post.

Go back to Toranna; they like guys you over there.

Je suis

Sieur Bugs Potter, écuyer. Major-général du dépôt de munitions Fort Gainey, contre-amiral du torpilleur de classe-II Sainte Flanelle, et sous-secrétaire du ministère de la Défense Tricolore.


ParrySoundHabber's picture

Please try and get a hold of yourself


Habitant in Surrey's picture

...TRANQUILIZERS !!! ...WHOSE GOT THE DAMN TRANQUILIZERS ???

......sheessh !

Habitant means PASSIONATE HOCKEY

http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=423049


aemarchand11's picture

Oh and furthermore.

Atlanta, NYR are not bottom feeders, check your stats. This isnt the 2008-2009 season, those teams have turned it around. We have two solid goalies, so get over it.

2009-2010 Return of the Habs


aemarchand11's picture

CP will not be back? Well as an RFA and if Mtl offers him a qualifying offer he will be back.

You heard it here, compliments of the CBA.

2009-2010 Return of the Habs


Not if others teams puts in a counter offer than the Habs cannot match. Just Like Kevin Lowe did to Dustin Penner and Loud mouth Burke could not match.


petefleet's picture

WE could only be so lucky.  Why do you guys want a goalie who's head is in the clouds?

Go Habs Go


aemarchand11's picture

I dont think that Burke gave Penner a qualifying offer for cap reasons at that time.. Same with Vanek, look at the Hawks this year they were scrambling to get qualifying offers so their RFA's could not be signed to an offer sheet.

 

 

2009-2010 Return of the Habs


Bugs's picture
'Member Andrei metionin that he always starts off slow? Lookin at the stats confirms it but...was it like this?

Dang, Andy, you need to wake the hell up, boy. This guy's fault, that guy's fault, your fault, my fault, your brother's fault, media's fault, I don't care. Just wake the hell up.

Cuz you could be beautiful, man!..(snif)...friggin beautiful.

Je suis

Sieur Bugs Potter, écuyer. Major-général du dépôt de munitions Fort Gainey, contre-amiral du torpilleur de classe-II Sainte Flanelle, et sous-secrétaire du ministère de la Défense Tricolore.


100HABS's picture

I like the lines, but I feel for poor Plecky - he's been working hard but has to adjust to different wingers all the time. Both are new to him now. I also thought Laps did okay with them but since Metro's out, Laps has to go back to center.

I would have gone with Price - can't let him get too cold either - but I'm ok with this decision and expect a W.


Habitant in Surrey's picture

...We can likely handle the Islanders without Metropolit ...BUT not the Penguins

...to Me ...Met is The One Guy that MAKES Us a legitimate 4 Line Team

...Met, Chipchura, Lapierre ...and a promising Pyatt ...mixing with the Moens, Latendresses, Stewarts, Paciorettis, d'Ags ...AND, possibly One or more of the Potato Head Bros ...makes for some solid mix'n'match depth potential behind the 3 Amigos...to keep opposing coaches off-balance

Habitant means PASSIONATE HOCKEY

http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=423049


Puck Bard's picture

Hate these lines: AK on fourth? Put him put of the line-up already! 


wmarcello's picture

After listening to the pre-game audio from Mr Martin, I feel a tiny bit better about AK on the fourth line. I think his logic is that AK needs to learn how to play in this new system, and the 4th line may give him a better chance to learn, by not having to play against the opposition's best players.


Puck Bard's picture

Woop, missed your post: if Martin articulated a reason for it, let's try it.


wmarcello's picture

Well, he didn't exactly say it in those words exactly. Part of that is me reading into his words. You can listen for yourself.


RetroMikey's picture

Let this be a lesson to Andre, your baby brother Sergei is not around, you are a married man and must socialize with other teammates of yours and grasp the English language more thouroughly.  Your English is pathetic Andre and you have been here for almost 6 years!  Do you care to learn at all or just want that weekly paycheque from the club?

You can be an actor at times along with Sergei but Martin is not stupid, he is demoting you on the 4th line.

If you want a career in the NHL, you better smarten up and change your work ethic or else it will be bye bye to you and your brother and go back to Belarus and play.

 

"We will win the Cup one day only with a mature Carey Price in the nets"


PrimeTime's picture

Nobody will argue that Andre is underperforming but I hardly think language has anything to do with it. The 4th line demotion is to get him engaged with a more physical game, He has never been the same since he took that headshot early last year but hockey is a contact game and until he can be comfortable with it he has no value as an NHL player.


Habsrule1's picture

I agree AK needs to step up his game and give a solid effort every night. It seems to be there for flashes, but not enough.

As for English, I couldn't give a rat's *** if he NEVER learns it....just play the game HARD every night and I'll be happy.

Go Habs Go!! "I can't hear what Jeremy (Roenick) is saying because my Stanley Cup rings are in my ears" - Patrick Roy


yeah. i don't think harping on his language issue is the solution to his lack of determination on the ice.

keep that for 110%. thanks.


wmarcello's picture

I thought Carey might get the start tonight, but Martin choosing to go with Halak doesn't surprise nor disappoint me.

I'm a little perplexed about that second line though. AK has been underperforming for some time now, and I'm doubtful this demotion will help. Mostly though I just feel bad for Pleks who has so much skill and is playing so well... now he is stuck with Dags and Lats. They're decent players, but not 2nd line material, and I doubt Pleks will have much to work with.


ddupuis's picture

The Dags, Lats and Chipcura line sure was impressive against the Rangers...seems silly to break that line up No?

DD...


J. Ambrose's picture

Yeah, at least keep one line in tact. And Pleks deserves to have Cammy on his wing. They've teamed up on two goals over the last couple of games. But we are woefully short on top-line forwards. If they don't want to release Sergei from purgatory, they better go find another forward!


anyone else worried by the apparent lack of depth upfront?  with AK46 playing so poorly and sergei down on the farm, our wings look vulnerable.

on the upside, the young guys are getting a lot of quality minutes.  they'll have to learn and improve quickly for us to be competitive.

 


matraque's picture

Finally... some fairness.

AK aka Hollow Man (I know, i'm a real joker) will go think about his future on the 4th line.

I think he will score tonight or have amazing shifts.

I wish the 2nd line was more like Cammy, Plek, Gui!

I'm happy for Halak.  JM knows what he is doing.  Price will start against the Pens... He's good against them.

--------------

We have a new team!

Mike Komisarek: (-2)-0-0

Gainey Haters bandwagon ---> This way


Frank2468's picture

I wonder with all that is going on with Sergei in Hamilton if it is starting to affect Andrei.  He's been in JM dog house a few times now, and down to the 4th line for tonight.  If that doesn't get the message across to him then nothing will.  So I wonder if they should trade Sergei if that will help Andrei or make matters worse.  I personally never liked brother tandems on a team.  Look at Koivu he could have gone to the Wild but he choose elsewhere.  I know that people are going to say look at the Sudins twins, but I think that is an anomaly.  They even a clause that they have to be traded together I believe.  Either way it's going to be interesting as to what plays out for the brothers on this team in the near future. 


Frank2468's picture

You guys are correct in mentioning the Rocket and the Pocket Rocket and the Frank and Peter Mahovlich.  As a matter of fact the only one I was to young to remember and didn't see playing was Maurice.  But with all due respect comparing Sergei and Andrei in the same sentence is a little ridiculous.  It was a different era and the guys played for different reasons as well.  Don't think the same kind of spirit and motivation can be expected from the Sergei and Andrei, this why I didn't mention the Mahovlichs or the Richards.  I was comparing to today's brother acts in the NHL.


A. Berke's picture

You forgot to mention one of the best we had: Mahovlich brothers. Or, maybe you are not old enough to remember them.

I believe there were more in the earlier days but those were before my time  :-)

cheers,

Ali B.


Don't forget the best 2 brothers combo of all time wearing the CH was "THE ROCKET" & "POCKET ROCKET". Who could ever forget these two brothers.!!!!!!


100HABS's picture

How about Rocket and Pocket Rocket? That is the best historical brother act for sure. They played 5 years together averaging 50 goals between them.


ddupuis's picture

I agree...outside of the Sedins, the Neidermeyer's in Anaheim, and let's not forget Larry and Moe Robinson, I think its only natural for one to side with his brother a little on any situation...so I understand what you mean.  Blood is thicker than water...

DD... 


avatar_58's picture

Considering how often I see the 4th line play on this team I don't even consider it a demotion - he just got moved to different linemates. Think about it, the habs always seem to play their 3rd and 4th lines a TONNE. So hey if he wants back up then start scoring.


punkster's picture

My God you people are hard to please. I've been on HI/O for a long time and this damn goaltender controversy thing just keeps getting worse. My advice to you all is try to find some happiness in life. Get out and go for a walk in the sunshine. Drop a few coins in the hand of a panhandler. Contribute a few bucks to a worthy charity. Do something to make you feel better about yourself. People, the Habs are winning, they're getting better, they have heart and soul and a good first line. As per Monty Python, "Always look on the bright side of life".

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WlBiLNN1NhQ


ddupuis's picture

The season is long - Carey will have PLENTY of opportunity to showcase his stuff...but what ever quarterback is throwing touchdowns is the one I want in the game.  Right now that is Halak.  When a goalie is winning, there is no controvery.  Now Toronto - that's a goaltending controversy as none of them can stop Komi from scoring on them...:)

DD...

 


mrhabby's picture

lol...right on d.


Mattyleg's picture

And also, am I the only one who wishes that Gomez would finish his rushes????

He has fantastic speed -reminds me of Guy Lafleur, the way he starts deep in our zone, and flies through the neutral zone, terrifying backpedalling defenders... but he always seems to pass it off, often onto a stick or into a play that breaks down!

Don't get me wrong, I'm very happy with the way he plays, he's exciting and talented, and is putting up points, but I want to see him challenge the defenders! Break through between them, and at least get a tripping call as they jam their sticks between his legs! Put a shot between their legs a la Ovie! Keep driving to the net and use that speed to push them back instead of fading to the sides!!

That's what I'd like to see. :)


avatar_58's picture

No, because what Cammalleri did in the last game is a rarity - not the norm. I LOVE seeing Gomez come close then - zip to Gionta and IN. Doesn't work every time but it keeps the goalie guessing. If he just shot it like a vanilla centerman then I don't think we'd be winning games.


Gotta Wear Shades's picture

A buddy of mine is a huge Rangers fan, and that is the exact way he described Gomez after the trade was announced and we were comparing notes.

He's a very talented stick handler (almost up there with Kovalev just for the fact he adds speed to his moves, whereas Kovy was slightly faster than Gill).

He's still finding his place with his line mates so I expect to see him start finishing more often very soon.


habs4_25th's picture

the hot hand will get the start, that is how you run a tandem of goalies.  Playing Price wouldn't be good if he is struggling when you have a goalie who is in the groove right now.  Why are we even arguing about who should start and who should sit.  I thought the main thing for us fans is that our teams wins.  I don't care who is in the net or who scores the goals.  The point is that we win as a team and hopefully have some success along the way!!!! GO HABS GO!!

"To you from failing hands we throw the torch. Be it yours to hold high."


i like Halak but The Hot Hand he ain't. let's settle down, here. he's been solid (save for his usual shakiness/rebound-giver/not knowing where the puck is) but he hasn't been stealing any games for the Habs this past week. the guys up front won us those games.


It seems to me that Price looks for the puck much more than Halak. He might not have stolen any games but the team had enough confidence in him to play the way they did.

I think you might have Halak and Price mixed up.


DillyDalley's picture

Price hasn't struggled this season. His players in front of him have.


ddupuis's picture

Couldn't agree more...


steeeve's picture

You are right.The team is playing tighter the last few games and everyone forgets Price stole the 1st two games of the year when they were badly outshot by Toronto and Buffalo.


++1 :) agreed.


Mattyleg's picture

Yep, I'm with JM...

And the whole idea of 'not being ready for games because you haven't played' is overrated. The goalies practice with the team, they prepare themselves. If that old adage actually had any truth in it, EVERY team would lose their first games of the season.

If Halak doesn't play well, Price will be hungry for the start against Pittsburgh. If Halak plays well, stick with him.

I like the posters on here who can look beyond their own favourites and as the team as a whole. Good point, avatar_58, as long as we win I don't care if it's Doug Soetaert playing in goal!!!

 


avatar_58's picture

Well hey I'll be the first to admit I'm biased and a price fanboy. However you know what I hate? Seeing the team lose. So props to Halak I guess.

Also frankly let's ease off the guy for the 5 goals against shall we? The defence had issues that game and it was the RANGERS. The so called "top team" other than the Pens. I don't agree with the moniker, but you have to admit their record looked good until the habs, whom everyone craps on, managed to beat them. So there.


pleks is playing better but looks like has lost his ability to put the puck in the net and still loses too many faceoffs when on for pk...secondary scoring will continue to be an issue unless one of our young forwards becomes a consistent scorer but as i said before none of them were scorers in any level before nhl...ak46 and his brother were counted on before the season to be the secondary scorers ..if they cannot do that ..we will need to pick up a scorer.


I predict Price will play in the next game Martin feels he should play in... how is that for going out on a limb. What I am really saying is 'don't worry about it'. We have a good man running the team who is all over it.


Can't get too excited about the proposed lines. They could change before the game and if they don't work, Martin will juggle them until they do. I am impressed with his performance so far - plans and adapts well - and I had high expectations.


Habsrule1's picture

Not a fan of keeping Price out of action. He has a good game against a weak team tonight and we have 2 goalies beaming with confidence. I'm not an NHL coach, so I have to believe JM is doing what he thinks is right. I simply disagree.

As for Pleks playing with AHL'ers, I disagree about Lats. The guy deserves a REAL shot as a top 6 forward. Give him 5 games and if he doesn't do the trick, put him back, but he's scored a fair amount of goals over his career on the 3rd line. I thought he played really well against the Rangers, and I'm glad JM saw that too.

Go Habs Go!! "I can't hear what Jeremy (Roenick) is saying because my Stanley Cup rings are in my ears" - Patrick Roy


CrashTheNetCrashTheNet's picture

Agreed with your assesment of Lats. I'll never understand why ppl are unhappy with his production. Sure he hasn't scored 30 goals but he's scored 18 (or so) with very limited ice time. I'd say thta even if he has plateaued (which I doubt as he's still really young) he's still a keeper. I mean how can you not be happy with a third liner who pots 18 goals???


Naila Jinnah's picture

Halak deserves the start. I'm glad Martin isn't succumbing to the pressures and politics of Montreal. There is no controversy. Get over it.

 

http://nailaj.blogspot.com


avatar_58's picture

That's what it boils down to. We all have a favourite goalie but let's be reasonable here - who really cares who starts as long as we win?


Habsrule1's picture

Actually, I don't have a favourite. This isn't a bad decision, but I think we're missing the chance to have 2 very good goalies with very high confidence levels due to playing well against a somewhat weak opponent. It's sort of a mind game, but a shutout or 1 goal game lifts a goalie, no matter who the opponent. Besides that, it's not too big a deal.

Go Habs Go!! "I can't hear what Jeremy (Roenick) is saying because my Stanley Cup rings are in my ears" - Patrick Roy


DillyDalley's picture

Martin has to play Halak against The Pens. He can't sit Price & then put him in against the best team in the league.


dont think this is right at all with halak , carey won us our 2 first games he was sat for calgary so he could have no support in vancouver and i am willing to bet carey couldve handled playing in calgary and vancouver back to back so this martin bringing in the philosphy you win your in shouldve been done  with our western road trip as i see halak played prety crappy sat night the team got the win not just the goalie as he looked sloppy and  price is supposed to be the number 1 goalie and shouldnt be sitting  for so long


BeachHabFan's picture

metro would be a bigger loss than CP not getting the start. where's the tamiflu at?


HabsInBlood's picture

Price doesn't play until i) a loss ... or maybe ii) a back to back.


i want him in against the leafs on saturday (which is back-to-back with Chicago friday night).


SlovakHab's picture

Regarding Halak - I wish we'd play Price - needs to stay sharp. But ok, Martin hopefully knows what he's doing.. But then why did he play Jaro against Calgary when CP was clearly hot? Maybe he could have stolen a point or two there.

As for AK46, I don't understand why would we sent him to AHL as some of the posters suggest. Are you completely out of your mind? We'd lose him on waivers in a hartbeat. He's an asset - an invisible asset who still could be traded for something else. But waiving him??? Are you all 16 years old?

Regards Metro - too bad! I'd rather have Laps on the wing on the 2nd line than Lats, but now we needs Lapierre centering our 3rd line.. And Metro is a class act and a very very useful player, I think we can all agree.

But suggesting Lats will never develop is another nonsense. Check out how many goals Franzen scored in a season in Sweden when he was 22. He scored 2 goals. Power forwards need time. Lats will be fantastic when he's 26, I believe.


likehoy's picture

regarding AK46...people gave kovalev sooo much patience, kovalev's "breakout year" was when he was 27-28...for the first time he exceeded a point per game average (95points in the 00-01 season) before that kovalev's career average in point totals was around 55...andrei kostitsyn's not too far off...especially in consistency issues :P.

i agree lats will develop...but being on the team from 19 makes him seem much older than he is...plekanec and higgins and komisarek all only broke into the league at 22-23, andrei kostitsyn's first full season was when he was 22...

but lats development is hindered because he never played in the AHL...he's lost a sense of how to play with responsibility, as he's played 3 years as a bit role.

- we need a MARKOV.


likehoy's picture

sucks that plekanec has to play with two AHLers...

- we need a MARKOV.


dudurules's picture

I agree... been Pleks' downfall... crappy support.  Or a half-assed Kovalev.


Mr.Hazard's picture

Shame to break up the 4th line, considering how well it did last game.

Ex nihilo nihil fit


dudurules's picture

Title should read "AK46 Traded"


Sakus Evil Twin's picture

As well as Halak has been playing I would have tested Price against the Islanders. 

Of course we shouldn't take them for granted, but the Isles are not the Penguins or the Blackhawks, and Price still needs games. Halak has earned the big games, no doubt, but why create a problem where there is none. I don't really give two hoots who starts tonight as I think that as long as the defense system does it's job tonight it'll be tough again for NYI, but from a player conditioning, motivation and management perspective it seems like a no brainer to me.

As for AK46, blech. He'll be back on the 2nd line by 10:00 of the 1st period.

Much to my chagrin.

It pains me to see a guy with his size, speed and moves play like little red riding hood.

With Metro out, does that mean that BGL is back? Or did I miss something?


Les-Habitants's picture

Stewart is getting the nod, or so it appears, instead of Laraque


Captain aHab's picture

I totally don't agree with the "if the goalie wins keep playing him philosophy". If the goalie plays real well and wins then yes, but if the goalie wins 7-6, then no.

The opposite is true...if the goalie loses 1-0 and plays great, why sit him?


Mr.Hazard's picture

Generally yes, but not necessarily: if a team wins 7-6 every time they play one goalie, and loses 1-0 every time they play the other, what should you do?

Ex nihilo nihil fit


Jaro deserves the start. He may not hove stole the show but he made key saves at key times and gave the boys a chance. This team plays totaly differend in front of Jaro. I don't know what it is but if i'm nervous when Price is in net imagine how the rest of the team must feel. Finally we have a coach. We're not getting out coached anymore and if the hard work continues we'll be a tough team to play against. I know it's early but we finally have something to be excited about.


Gary320's picture

WOW.

Hmm just wow.

Im happy that Halak is in, regardless of wehater you think he deserves it or not... He was part of our 3 game winning streak, keep him in anyway..

Honestly, if this was Carbo.. Price would have gotten the start vs NYR or tonight.

But the second line is ???  I'm very interested to see what happens with Latendresse and Dagostini on the wing.

 


petefleet's picture

My post from the weekend...it's prophetic.

If Martin goes with Price on Monday he really is a moron.  Do you think Torts will pull Lunquist for the next game....he let in 5 !!!  Halak got the win and from where I was sitting had little to no chance on the goals that went in.  No one can stop every odd man rush.

 

Chips had a fantastic game.  I hope he keeps it up.  AK46 should join his brother in Hamilton or start playing the 4th line on Monday.

 

Great game by the "little three".  Cammellarie was awsome.  Gionta's second effort is second only to Crosby

 Go Habs Go


sholi2000.com's picture

Well Pete you were right.  Looks like Halak also gets the Pens and Hawks this week.  Very odd indeed.  Where was this win and your in When Price stole the first two games?  All I can say is this.  Looks like Halak is being showcased, and that's fine by me ;)

 

They call me Shane


Mr.Hazard's picture

Showcasing, in order to trade? Jaro has more wins than Carey, why trade him lol.

Ex nihilo nihil fit


DillyDalley's picture

From what i've read, people seem the think that Carey should stop every odd man rush.


petefleet's picture

No one can stop all of them, even Carey.  The thing is he'll get his chance when and if Halak suffers a bad loss.  That's the way it should be anyway (IMO).

Go Habs Go


lavie's picture

WOW, JM is the boss!


Dintrox's picture

Did AK even play on Saturday? He was invisible on the ice. If he doesn't wake up he will soon find a home in the press box.

Elmer Lach's #16 jersey should be raised to the rafters.


andrewberkshire's picture

So after Halak starts 4 straight game, in which he was either never challenged or let in a goal every time the other team had a great chance (against the Rangers), is this the end of the Halak fanboys saying he's been treated unfairly? I ask because the last game I was very nervous with the way Jaro was playing. He was extremely jittery and looked uncomfortable under pressure. I have no doubt that he'll beat the Islanders, because it is the Islanders after all. But to say he's "earned" this start after he would have had a big L on any other night of the season when our offense wasn't clicking.... What a joke.

For all those who said Price was playing bad, he's let in more than 3 goals ONCE this season. In a game where our team played terrible and abandoned defense. Halak has already let in more than 3 twice in 4 starts. If the tables were turned here, we'd have 100 people calling for Carey's head and screaming about how unfairly Halak is being treated.

I'm assuming Halak gets the start against the Penguins because he'll win tonight. So then does Price start against the Hawks after sitting for almost 2 weeks? I see that as setting him up for failure. Does Halak start again against the Hawks no matter what? And then Price plays the Leafs in the back to back? Sitting Price for 7 games would be understandable if he was playing terrible, but he wasn't. This is such a bad decision by Martin.

__________________________________________

http://berkshireonthehabs.blogspot.com/


jmsheehy19's picture

I only watched the condensed version of the game so maybe I didn't see everything, but I would say the first three weren't his fault, and the 4th one was against Gaborik on a breakaway. He certainly didn't play a bad game. And to say Jaro hasn't been challenged in the last 4 games is just flat out incorrect. 

Has the defence and the team performed better overall in these past 4 games than in the previous 6? Without question. Has Price played badly when he was in? Not really, aside from maybe a goal or two I think he's played very well. Should Pricey get the start tonight? Maybe, but I find it difficult to say Jaro shouldn't either.


petefleet's picture

If I could DISAGREE with you more I would but I don't know how.  Your logic is severely flawed (imo).  Did the Canucks keep Loungo out when he had severeal bad games?  Will Lunquist be in the next game for the Rangers?  Halak is winning.  The goals don't matter as long as the team is winning.  You can't punish a guy for a win.  Price will get his chance but thankfully not as many as last year.  If Carey had sat a little more last year, the Habs would have won more games.

Go Habs Go


andrewberkshire's picture

Jaroslav Halak is not Roberto Luongo or Henrik Lundqvist. Even making that comparison is downright foolish. If you think my logic is flawed, perhaps re-read your own comment before posting.

Halak didn't EARN the win last night, he happened to not get pulled after letting in several momentum sapping goals, while the team dug him out of a rut and won the game. Halak isn't winning, the team is.

If Carey would have sat a bit more we would have won more? That's why Carey had one of the best records in the NHL before he suffered a high ankle sprain in January? After which Halak was brutal which forced Price to come back 3 weeks after the injury, instead of the 2 months most take to heal after a high ankle sprain?Halak had a little hot streak last year in February and somehow that has fanboys like yourself thinking he's the greatest. He's only played average to slightly below average the last 3 games.

__________________________________________

http://berkshireonthehabs.blogspot.com/


petefleet's picture

You're right.  My post is a little unclear.  I was not comparing Jaro to Loungo or Lundquist.  I was comparing coaching.  Halak got the win even though he allowed 4 goals.  My point is he should not be punished for that.  Beat on Halak all you want, Price is not the goalie alot of you guys want him to be and may never be.  On the other hand, Halak has no expectations and continues to play excellent hockey.

As for last year, Price sucked after Xmas.  It was obvious to everyone that he was struggling mentally.  Gainey kept on playing him and not because Jaro sucked, because he's Gainey's prize draft pick.  There is no reason Price can't spend this year trying to earn the #1 spot instead of it being forced fed to him.

Go Habs Go